Introduction
Cerebral palsy (CP) is a disorder of movement and posture caused by nonprogressive injury to immature brain.1 The incidence is two to three per thousand live births.2 Spastic CP is the most common subtype which is seen in 70% to 80% of CP patients.3 In the patient with CP, there is change in muscle tone and posture which is evident both during rest and voluntary activity.4 Foot deformities e.g., ankle equinus, equinovarus and equinovalgus, are common in patients with CP. Varus deformity which is usually accompanied by equinus, is commonly caused by an abnormal posterior tibial muscle that is overactive or firing out of phase. In normal individuals posterior tibial muscle is active during stance phase to stabilize the foot and inactive during swing phase. In patients with CP the posterior tibial muscle contracts during swing phase causing varus position of the foot at heel strike. The anterior tibial muscle dysfunction may be associated. The gastrocnemius and soleus contracture usually accompanies the varus contracture and hence contributes to the vaurs deformity of foot. EMG studies are helpful in determining the activity of muscles.5 5 Spastic equinovarus deformity, if left untreated, may cause severe fixed foot deformity and painful callosities under metatarsal heads and on the lateral side of the foot. The gait pattern becomes less effective and needs more energy.6 Various methods of treatment had been advocated over the years for equino varus foot in patients with CP. The procedures practiced and recommended have been, ·split transfer of tibialis anterior tendon to the cuboid.7 Split transfer of tibialis posterior tendon to the peroneus brevis tendon8 split transfer of tibialis posterior tendon anteriorly through interosseous membraneto lateral cuniform9 rerouting of tibialisposterior tendon anterior to medial malleolus.10 Tenotomy of tibialis posterior tendon.11 Shortening of tibialis anterior tendon.12 In this study the patients with forefoot varus and aquinus were treated by split transfer of tibialis anterior to the lateral cuniform. Percutaneus lengtheningof tendocalcaneus was performed in all patients. The outcome was analyzed. Split tendon transfer as compared to whole tendon transfer is considered more effective as it distributes equally the muscle power and eliminates the possibility of residual deformity or over correction.13 Bony procedure is needed in rigid foot deformity.14
Aims and Objective
To evaluate the effectiveness of split transfer of tibialis anterior for equinovarus foot deformity in spastic cerebral palsy children.
Materials and Methods
A prospective non randomizied study was carried out in the Department of Orthopaedic December 2014 to 2016. 40 (27 hemiplegic and 13 diplegic) spastic cerebral palsy children in the age group of 5 to 15 years with flexible varus foot deformity(predominantly forefoot and midfoot inversion) who were ambulatory or had potential for ambulation with confusion test positive were included in the study. The foot which showed overactivity of tibialis posterior were excluded from the study.
Procedure
Tendoachilles lengthening was done in all cases. Steindler’s procedure was done if cavus was present. Split tibialis anterior tendon transfer to lateral cuneiform was done: (Hoffer et al 1974).7 Post-operatively below knee cast was given for 6 weeks. Then ankle foot orthosis(AFO) was prescribed for 6 months along with tendon re-education program. Pre-treatment gross motor functional classification system (GMFCS) levels were compared to the patients' latest evaluations. Factors associated with outcomes and success rate were assessed.
Figure 1
Case 1- A,B,C): The surgical procedure; D): Adequate length of the splittend on was achieved; E): The split tendon was passed subcutaneously into the incision made over the lateral cuneiform and was then inserted into the hole made in the bone under moderate tension; F): Post-operatively pop B.K. cast was given for 6 weeks
Statistics
Hoffer’s criteria
Table 1
Table 2
According to GMFCS
|
GMFCS |
Initial no. of children in different GMFCS level |
Improvement in GMFCS level of CP children at follow up after 1.5yrs |
|
I |
3 |
5 |
|
II |
21 |
23 |
|
III |
12 |
9 |
|
IV |
4 |
3 |
|
V |
0 |
0 |
There is no significant difference between initial and follow-up data as witnessed by Wilcoxon’s Signed Rank Test (p > 0.05). But looking at the individual performances, some advantage of the treatment can be noticed.
Result
Fourty patients (40 unilateral feets) were included in the study. Thirty two patients were male and eight patients were female. The age range at start of sturdy was between five and fifteen years (mean age 10years). Mean follow-up was 1.5 years (Range 1-2 years).28 patients were hemiplegic and 12 patients were diplegic. The range of varus deformity was 15° to 20° and range of equinus was between 16° to 25°.
The result of the study was carried out using the clinical criteria of Hoffer. The feet were graded as very good in 75%, satisfactory in 25% and poor in 5% of cases. In the follow up period of one year, in 28 feet there was no deformity post-operatively, total foot contact on the ground and proper shoe wearing was present, in 10 feet there was mild varus or equinus deformity (less than 5°) and patient was prescribed ankle foot orthosis for overnight use, in 2 feet there was under correction of equinus (>5°) and orthosis was prescribed for daytime use. Percutaneus tendocalcaneuas lengthening was done in all cases. Patients with excellent and very good results showed improvement in gait and were able to walk with plantigrade feet. They were wearing regular shoes and do not need brace. The patients with good results were advised to wear night splint. The patients with poor results needed brace during walking and at night as well. Pre-treatment gross motor functional classification system (GMFCS) levels were compared to the patients' latest evaluations. Factors associated with outcomes and success rate were assessed. As per Table 2, GMFCS Level improvement seen in 40 patients in Level I to V.
Discussion
Spastic tibialis anterior is most often the cause of varus–inversion deformity of forefoot and midfoot. When the tibialis anterior muscle is over-active or tight, it tends to pull the foot in. The muscles which balance this movement on the outside of the foot are often weak and unable to keep the foot in a normal position. Split transfer utilizes the spastic nature of the muscle to counter balance the deformity caused by the original muscle. This surgery balances the pull of the muscle so that the foot lifts straight up instead of pulling in. Hence, it is a better solution to the problem. However accurate diagnosis of deforming muscle, i.e. tibialis anterior or tibialis posterior is essential to produce good result. Percutaneus tendo calcaneus lengthening was done in all cases. Percutaneous tendo calcaneus lengthening has shorter operating time, lower complication rate and gives better active dorsal and plantar flexion abilities.15 Lengthening of the tendon weakens the muscle. With additional lengthening of tendo calcaneus the planter flexion strength is reduced.
Equino varus deformity of foot in patients with cerebral palsy has been treated by various methods. Baker and Hill (1964)10 advocated rerouting of the tibialis posterior tendon anterior to the medial malleolus with satisfactory results, but Bislaet at (1976)16 failed to achieve the adequate correction of deformity in their patients. Banks and Panagakos (1967)17 described lengthening of tibialis posterior in these cases. On long term follow up many authors reported high incidence of recurrence after lengthening of tibialis posterior (Ruda and Frost 1971)14 (Root et al 1987).18 Lengthening of the tendon weakens the muscle. With additional lengthening of tendo calcaneus the planter flexion strength is reduced. Tenotomy of tibialis posterior tendon at the site of its insertion resulted in many cases into collapse of talonavicular joint. (Green et al 1983)11 (Root et al 1987)18 Kaufer H (1977)19 and Kling TF et al (1985)8 reported their results of split transfer of tibialis posterior tendon to the peroneus brevis passing posterior to the tibia. The results were satisfactory but their study included patients who developed spasticity after encephalitis and head injuries. Grzegorzewski A et al (2007)6 reported 89% good clinical and functional results after 4.6 years of follow up after split tibialis posterior transfer to peroneus brevis tendon. M.J. Saji et al (1993),9 reported their results of surgical procedure for spastic equinovarus deformity of foot in patients with cerebral palsy. They transfer the anterior half of the split tibialis posterior to the dorsum of the foot through the interosseous membrane on 23 feet in 18 children. In their 8.4 years of follow up, using the criteria of Kling et al. (1985)8 excellent results were obtained in 14 feet, good in eight, and poor result in only one.
The result of the study was carried out using the clinical criteria of Hoffer. The feet were graded as very good in 75%, satisfactory in 25% and poor in 5% of cases. In the follow up period of one year, in 28 feet there was no deformity post-operatively, total foot contact on the ground and proper shoe wearing was present, in 10 feet there was mild varus or equinus deformity(less than 5°) and patient was prescribed ankle foot orthosis for overnight use, in 2 feet there was under correction of equinus (>5°) and orthosis was prescribed for daytime use. Percutaneus tendocalcaneuas lengthening was done in all cases. Pre-treatment gross motor functional classification system (GMFCS) levels were compared to the patients' latest evaluations. Factors associated with outcomes and success rate were assessed. Patients with excellent and very good results showed improvement in gait and were able to walk with plantigrade feet.
Conclusion
Spastic T.A. is most often the cause of varus of forefoot. Split transfer utilises the spastic nature of the muscle to counter balance the deformity caused by the original muscle. Hence, it is better solution to the problem. However accurate diagnosis of deforming muscle, i.e, T.A or T.P. is essential to produce good result.
Timely surgical intervention with an individualized approach in the treatment of foot deformity has a definitive role in the rehabilitation of cerebral palsy children. Long term follow- up is needed to see the actual effect of the surgery.
However accurate diagnosis of deforming muscle prior to surgery is essential to achieve the optimum results. The dynamic electromyography and gait analysis should be performed before surgery.
